[FIXED] What it the real benefit from Erlang's fault tolerance for a web project?

Issue

Let's assume we have a web project in which we want to have ~10000 web clients connected to the server simultaneously. Let's also assume that one client session lasts about 25 minutes.

If we compare LAMP stack or any other popular web stack/framework (Ruby on Rails with Apache on Linux, etc.) to a web project built in Erlang/OTP - what does Erlang/OTP have in terms of fault tolerance that other frameworks don't?

What event can happen to a client that will cause the whole LAMP stack crash, while Erlang/OTP will stand its ground?

Solution

Note that a typical LAMP-stack does employ some fault tolerance. In particular, if a request in the LAMP stack fail, only that request will, while the rest of the code will run on. This kind of protection allows you to have faults in a single request without that hurting other requests.

Erlang provides this idea of "able to cope with smaller unforseen errors" at a much finer grained scale. You may have other subsystems in an application, and the same kind of tolerance to errors can be extended to those. You won't get it "for free", but the tooling is there to build a system which is robust. Imagine a client error in the LAMP stack. This will often lead to a disconnect of that client. It may not be so in Erlang and the client can keep on running.

For a system of 10000 clients, Erlang provides the advantage that you can have a process per client. Or perhaps 10 processes per client. That is much harder to pull of in many languages since a process/thread is rather heavy and expensive. Note that interprocess communication between the clients are easy, also if some clients are on another machine (imagine extending to a distributed cluster some day).

If you write your code in a certain way, you can make sure that if a client crashes, for one reason or the other, then its state is properly cleaned up by other processes. That can avoid lots and lots of small nasty leaks in state as well.

Answered By - I GIVE CRAP ANSWERS