[FIXED] Which is the advantage of using CakePHP Console / Shell for programmed tasks

Issue

I am currently executing a programmed task calling directly to a Controller action by URL. (using the windows 2003 server programming task manager)

I've seen some people use the CakePHP console or shell for this kind of operations.

Which is the advantage of using it if any?

My action is currently calling multiple controllers and making use of a vendor library.

Thanks.

Solution

Here are a few reasons that come to mind:

• A shell isn't publicly accessible, where a url (generally) is
• A shell doesn't hit your webserver
• The shell dispatch process has less overhead
• Shell output is easier to log error vs. output

I could go into separation of concerns, but that's usually opinion-driven. I think the first two points are reason enough.

Answered By - jeremyharris

Answer Checked By - Marilyn (PHPFixing Volunteer)