[FIXED] How can a module defined in a .ml file reference itself

Issue

I am trying to define a Point module that defines a type to represent 2d points.

I would also like to include a submodule Point.Set so that Point.Set.t is a type meaning 'a set of Points'. That seems logical and convenient, but I am not able to figure out how to make the 'circular' reference that this involves.

I tried this:

file: point.ml (implicitly defines a 'Point' module)

type t = {x: int; y:int}

let compare {x=x1;y=y1} {x=x2;y=y2} = ...implementation omitted for brevity...

module Set = Stdlib.Set.Make(Point)
                         (*  ^^^^^ Internal path Mylib__Point is dangling *)

When I dune build the Mylib project/library this is in. I get an error:

Internal path Mylib__Point is dangling.
  The compiled interface for module Mylib__Point was not found.

I am not entirely sure what the error really means, but I gather it probably has something to do with the fact that we are trying to reference the Point module from within itself. And maybe that is not allowed?

I can work around this by instead defining a separate 'pointSet.ml' file and in there have include Set.Make(Point). Now I have a module called PointSet. That is okay, but I still would find it a bit more 'aesthetically pleasing' if Point.Set could be a submodule of Point instead. Is there a way to make this work?

Solution

If you don't mind a little bit of boilerplate, I think this solution may suit you:

point.ml

module Point = struct
  type t = { x : int; y : int }

  let compare { x = x1; y = _y1 } { x = x2; y = _y2 } = x1 - x2
end

module Set : Set.S with type elt = Point.t = Set.Make (Point)

include Point

You'll have access to Point.Set and since point.ml includes the module Point at the end of the file, you won't have to do Point.Point.compare ... in other files.

---

[EDIT]

I previously made the modules mutually recursive but in this case it's useless. If you need them to be mutually recursive you'll have to explicit their signatures:

point.ml

module rec Point : sig
  type t

  val compare : t -> t -> int
end = struct
  type t = { x : int; y : int }

  let compare { x = x1; y = _y1 } { x = x2; y = _y2 } = x1 - x2
end

and Set : (Stdlib.Set.S with type elt = Point.t) = Stdlib.Set.Make (Point)

include Point

Answered By - Lhooq

Answer Checked By - Mildred Charles (PHPFixing Admin)