[FIXED] Why doesn't await on Task.WhenAll throw an AggregateException?

Issue

In this code:

private async void button1_Click(object sender, EventArgs e) {
    try {
        await Task.WhenAll(DoLongThingAsyncEx1(), DoLongThingAsyncEx2());
    }
    catch (Exception ex) {
        // Expect AggregateException, but got InvalidTimeZoneException
    }
}

Task DoLongThingAsyncEx1() {
    return Task.Run(() => { throw new InvalidTimeZoneException(); });
}

Task DoLongThingAsyncEx2() {
    return Task.Run(() => { throw new InvalidOperation();});
}

I expected WhenAll to create and throw an AggregateException, since at least one of the tasks it was awaiting on threw an exception. Instead, I'm getting back a single exception thrown by one of the tasks.

Does WhenAll not always create an AggregateException?

Solution

I don't exactly remember where, but I read somewhere that with new async/await keywords, they unwrap the AggregateException into the actual exception.

So, in catch block, you get the actual exception and not the aggregated one. This helps us write more natural and intuitive code.

This was also needed for easier conversion of existing code into using async/await where the a lot of code expects specific exceptions and not aggregated exceptions.

-- Edit --

Got it:

An Async Primer by Bill Wagner

Bill Wagner said: (in When Exceptions Happen)

...When you use await, the code generated by the compiler unwraps the AggregateException and throws the underlying exception. By leveraging await, you avoid the extra work to handle the AggregateException type used by Task.Result, Task.Wait, and other Wait methods defined in the Task class. That’s another reason to use await instead of the underlying Task methods....

Answered By - decyclone

Answer Checked By - Willingham (PHPFixing Volunteer)